Tuesday, 23 Apr 2024

The Ultimate Everton Squad of the Premier League Era

Boyhood Blues, FA Cup winners, Premier League record-breakers and five Scousers. This is the ultimate Everton squad of the Premier League era.

Everton Football Club has a rich history, and the Premier League era has seen some exceptional players wear the Royal Blue jersey. From legendary goalkeepers to hard-tackling defenders and creative midfield maestros, Everton has had it all. In this article, we will explore the greatest Everton squad of the Premier League era, featuring the best players chosen by the fans.

Manager: David Moyes (2002-13)

David Moyes took charge of Everton in 2002 and transformed the club into a competitive force. Despite limited resources, Moyes built a tightly-knit, solid unit that could compete with any team in the league. Under his management, Everton achieved an FA Cup final appearance and regularly challenged for European qualification. Moyes’s focus on character and attitude brought success to Goodison Park and endeared him to the fans.

David Moyes

Assistant: Joe Royle (1966-74, 1994-97)

Joe Royle, an Everton legend, played a crucial role in the club’s history. As a player, he scored over 100 goals for Everton and captained the side. Royle later returned to Goodison Park as a manager and led the Toffees to FA Cup glory in 1995. His influence on the team was evident, and Everton even became Premier League title contenders under his guidance. Although Royle couldn’t secure a permanent spot in the starting XI, his impact on the club’s success cannot be overlooked.

Joe Royle

Under 23s Manager: David Unsworth (1992-97, 1998-2004, 2014- )

David Unsworth may not have made it into the starting lineup, but his unwavering loyalty and commitment to Everton make him an integral part of the club’s history. Unsworth, a true Evertonian, played for the club across three different spells and is now involved in coaching the Under 23s. His dedication to the club and his deep connection with the fans make him a deserving member of the squad.

David Unsworth

Starting XI

Goalkeeper — Neville Southall (1981-98)

Neville Southall is widely regarded as one of Everton’s greatest players. With 750 appearances for the Toffees, including 207 in the Premier League, Southall was a colossal presence between the sticks. He played a crucial role in Everton’s FA Cup triumph in 1995, making remarkable saves and defying the laws of physics. Southall’s commanding presence, exceptional shot-stopping ability, and love for Everton make him an undisputed choice as the goalkeeper in the ultimate Everton squad.

Tham Khảo Thêm:  It's Football Season! - Grasses on High Profile Sports Fields

Right-Back — Seamus Coleman (2009- )

Seamus Coleman is one of the best bargains in Premier League history, signed for just £60,000. Known for his heart, determination, and relentless work rate, Coleman became the captain of Everton. He marauds up and down the wing, using his grit and power to beat opponents. Coleman’s commitment to the club for over a decade and his leadership qualities make him an indispensable member of the starting XI.

Left-Back — Leighton Baines (2007- )

Leighton Baines is considered one of the coolest players to ever wear the Royal Blue jersey. Known for his wand of a left foot, ingenuity, and class, Baines is the Penalty King of Everton. He consistently provided assists and scored screamers from range. Baines’ contribution to the team has been immense, and he is a legend in every sense of the word. His creativity and attacking prowess from the left-back position make him an automatic choice in the ultimate Everton squad.

Centre-Back — Dave Watson (C) (1986-2001)

Dave Watson, the triumphant FA Cup-winning captain, was an indomitable force at the back for Everton. Known for his bravery in the air and strength in the tackle, Watson led by example on and off the pitch. His heroic performance in the 1995 FA Cup final, including an instrumental contribution to Everton’s winning goal, remains etched in the club’s history. Watson’s leadership qualities, defensive prowess, and longevity at Everton make him the skipper of the ultimate Everton squad.

Centre-Back — Phil Jagielka (2007-19)

Phil Jagielka was a consistent performer during his 12 years at Everton and commanded immense respect in the dressing room. Known for his solid defending, masterful tackling, and the occasional spectacular goal, Jagielka was a reliable presence in Everton’s backline. He formed a formidable partnership with Watson and provided stability at the heart of the defense. Jagielka’s consistent performances, leadership qualities, and dedication to the club make him an essential member of the ultimate Everton squad.

Tham Khảo Thêm:  Choosing the Right Turf Shoes for Indoor Sports

Right Midfield — Andrei Kanchelskis (1995-97)

Andrei Kanchelskis quickly became a fan-favorite during his time at Everton. With his electrifying pace, quick feet, and direct style of play, the Russian winger mesmerized the Goodison Park faithful. Kanchelskis’s goals against Liverpool and his hat-trick against Sheffield Wednesday showcased his immense talent. His ability to beat defenders effortlessly and change games made him an irreplaceable player in the ultimate Everton squad.

Left Midfield — Steven Pienaar (2007-11, 2012-16)

Steven Pienaar was one half of Everton’s greatest double act of the Premier League era alongside Leighton Baines. Pienaar’s telepathic relationship with Baines down the left flank created numerous opportunities for the team. Known for his craft, quick thinking, and ability to create chances, Pienaar was a joy to watch. His emotional return to Goodison Park during his second spell at the club demonstrated his deep connection with Everton. Pienaar’s intelligence, skill, and impact on the team earns him a spot in the starting XI.

Central Midfield — Mikel Arteta (2005-11)

Mikel Arteta was a magician in the middle of the park for Everton. With his sumptuous touch, creativity, and footballing intelligence, Arteta was a joy to watch. He possessed the ability to keep the ball and distribute it with precision. Arteta’s majestic playing style, silky smooth skills, and ability to read the game made him a class above. His memorable strike against Fiorentina showcased his quality and secured a special place in Everton fans’ hearts.

Attacking Midfield — Tim Cahill (2004-12)

Tim Cahill, known as the “Wizard of Oz,” embodied the spirit of Everton Football Club. With his grit, passion, and never-say-die attitude, Cahill was a true inspiration on the pitch. He had an uncanny ability to score crucial goals, especially with his trademark headers. Cahill’s aerial prowess and leadership qualities made him a constant threat to the opposition. His dedication to the badge and his impact on the team’s success make him an undeniable member of the ultimate Everton squad.

Striker — Wayne Rooney (2002-04, 2017-18)

Wayne Rooney, a once-in-a-lifetime talent, had a deep affinity for Everton Football Club. Coming from a family of Evertonians, Rooney idolized Duncan Ferguson and fulfilled his dream of playing for the club. Rooney burst onto the scene with an extraordinary goal against Arsenal at the age of 16, showcasing his immense talent. His all-around skillset, versatility, and hunger for success made him an exceptional player. Rooney returned to Everton later in his career and had the privilege of scoring against Liverpool at Anfield. Rooney’s undeniable talent and love for the club make him an essential member of the ultimate Everton squad.

Tham Khảo Thêm:  The Love for Football: Countries that Embrace the Beautiful Game

Striker — Romelu Lukaku (2013-17)

Romelu Lukaku stands as one of the best goal scorers in Everton’s history and the Premier League. Known for his explosive pace, physicality, and goal-scoring prowess, Lukaku terrorized defenses throughout his time at Everton. He holds the record for being Everton’s top goal-scorer in the Premier League. Lukaku’s ability to find the back of the net regularly and his hunger for goals make him an indispensable member of the ultimate Everton squad.


The ultimate Everton squad also includes a strong bench, comprising talented players who narrowly missed out on starting positions. Here are some notable substitutes:

  • Nigel Martyn (Goalkeeper)
  • Lucas Digne (Left-Back)
  • Joleon Lescott (Centre-Back)
  • Gary Speed (Central Midfield)
  • Richarlison (Right Midfield)
  • Duncan Ferguson (Striker)
  • Kevin Campbell (Striker)


1. Who is the greatest manager in Everton’s Premier League era?

The greatest manager in Everton’s Premier League era is David Moyes. His remarkable achievements and transformation of the club make him an iconic figure at Goodison Park.

2. Who is the all-time top goal scorer for Everton in the Premier League?

Romelu Lukaku holds the record for being Everton’s all-time top goal scorer in the Premier League. He scored a remarkable number of goals during his time at the club.

3. Which player is known as the Wizard of Oz?

Tim Cahill is known as the Wizard of Oz. His passion, dedication, and ability to score crucial goals made him a fan-favorite and an Everton legend.


The ultimate Everton squad of the Premier League era is a testament to the rich history and exceptional talent that Everton Football Club has witnessed. From legendary goalkeepers to inspiring captains and clinical goal scorers, this squad represents the very best in Everton’s illustrious history. These players have left an indelible mark on the club and will forever be remembered as legends by the Everton faithful.

For more information and updates on Everton players and their statistics, visit Pesstatsdatabase.